False Claims Act Basics – Known Overpayment Becomes False Claim

November 7, 2016

The Federal False Claims Act (“FCA”) provides a very strong enforcement tool to the federal government.  The FCA also provides the opportunity for whistleblowers to bring “qui tam” cases and collect a portion of the recovery where false claims are proved against the federal government.

FCA recovery was originally intended to provide a remedy against unscrupulous civil war profiteers.  Penalties were enhanced when the FCA was dragged off the shelf in the 1980s in reaction to some of the overpricing of government contracts selling supplies to the federal government.

Recently, the FCA has become one of the government’s prime enforcement tools to deter fraud in the federal health care programs. Historically, the FCA has been available when a health care provider falsely bills for covered services.  Triple damages and a $22,000 per claim penalty provide a strong deterrent in an industry that may make hundreds of claims per day.

Recent legislation has expanded FCA liability to claims that the provider knows resulted in an overpayment if the provider does not make repayment within 60 days of obtaining knowledge of the wrongfully billed amount.  Some of the potential applications of this that makes a simple overpayment a false claim has generated much discussion among health care lawyers and compliance officers alike.  An organization deemed to have knowledge of the overpayment has been the subject of much speculation due to the ambiguities that exist in the new rule.

It may be helpful to frame this discussion by touching on the general requirements that must be met in order to prove any claim under the Federal False Claims Act.  The three general elements that must be proved include:

  1. The submission of a claim to the federal government. In the health care context, the claim will normally be submitted to a government health program.

  2. The claim must be false.

  3. The claim must have been submitted knowingly.  Actual knowledge that the claim was false will always prove the knowledge requirement.  However, a FCA case can also be built around the submission of a claim with “reckless disregard” for its truth or falsity.

Recent health care legislation, in particular the Fraud Enforcement Recovery Act of 2009, greatly expanded the scope of the FCA.  The FCA is now applicable to a wide variety of situations that would not have previously been covered.  For example, the failure to return an identified overpayment now becomes a false claim.  The potential remedies that a provider may face for not promptly repaying known overpayments creates a strong incentive for health care providers to monitor and audit their claims and set up processes that will catch improper billing that could ripen into the FCA.

Reckless disregard or hiding your head in the sand like an ostrich is no longer a way to avoid massive potential FCA liability.  Compliance programs need to be amended appropriately to address the new potential legal and financial risk presented by these new penalties.  The compliance program should require active identification of potential risk areas.  Based on identification of risks, an audit program should be implemented to identify any potential compliance infractions.  Once identified, affirmative actions should be taken to correct the situation, make appropriate repayment, and/or self-disclose the violation to the government.

Back to all News & Insights


The content in the following blog posts is based upon the state of the law at the time of its original publication. As legal developments change quickly, the content in these blog posts may not remain accurate as laws change over time. None of the information contained in these publications is intended as legal advice or opinion relative to specific matters, facts, situations, or issues. You should not act upon the information in these blog posts without discussing your specific situation with legal counsel.

© 2023 Ruder Ware, L.L.S.C. Accurate reproduction with acknowledgment granted. All rights reserved.